AI生成図版に関する学術誌の規定

AI生成図版に関する学術誌の規定

A license to use an AI-generated illustration is not the same as a journal’s acceptance of that image. Publishers set their own limits, and those limits differ. This article summarizes accessible official policies, reviewed on 14 November 2026, and identifies the Science page we could not retrieve. It is a starting map, not a substitute for the journal’s own instructions. A longer version, with a comparison table and FAQ, is on the journal policy guide.

Read the journal you are submitting to

A few practical points apply everywhere we looked:

  • The author remains responsible. No publisher we checked allows an AI tool to be listed as an author.

  • Disclosure is usually required when AI was used to generate or substantially modify a figure. The exact place for that statement (cover letter, Methods, caption, or a dedicated declaration) differs by publisher.

  • Primary research images are treated more strictly than explanatory diagrams. Microscopy, western blots, histology, radiology, and patient images are repeatedly singled out as images that must not be created or altered with generative AI.

  • Policies change. Elsevier’s page notes an update in June 2026. Always open the journal’s current official page, not a memory of last year’s rule.

JAMA and Cell Press are outside this comparison. Check the instructions of the specific journal you intend to submit to.

ICMJE

The International Committee of Medical Journal Editors recommendations, in the sections on authors’ use of AI and on preparing a manuscript, say that journals should require authors to disclose at submission whether they used AI-assisted technologies, including “image creators,” in the production of the submitted work. Authors should describe how they used the technology in the cover letter and, where applicable, in the submitted work. If AI was used for figure generation, that use should be described in the Methods.

ICMJE also states that AI tools should not be listed as authors, that humans are responsible for submitted material that included AI, and that authors should review the output because it can be incorrect, incomplete, or biased. Authors should be able to assert that there is no plagiarism in the paper, including in images produced by AI. Nondisclosure may be treated as misconduct in some circumstances.

ICMJE is a recommendation to journals, not a single house style. A journal may be stricter.

Elsevier

Elsevier’s official “Generative AI policies for journals,” checked on 14 November 2026 (the page states that the policy was updated in June 2026), permits AI tools for manuscript support only with human oversight. Authors must include a separate AI declaration on submission, naming the tool, the purpose, and the extent of oversight.

On figures, Elsevier divides images into categories:

  • Explanatory images (for example flow charts, decision trees, timelines, schematic conceptual illustrations, or experimental workflow diagrams) may be created with AI tools. The tool, version, and how it was used should be disclosed in each image caption and in the general AI declaration.

  • Data visualizations may use AI only when the output is derived directly from underlying data with reproducible methods, disclosed in the Methods section. AI must not fabricate or alter data.

  • Primary research images (microscopy, histology, western blots, radiology scans, or patient images) must not be created or altered with AI tools.

  • Graphical abstracts: “General-purpose generative AI image tools must not be used to create graphical abstracts.” Elsevier encourages dedicated scientific illustration tools and, in its FAQ, names BioRender and Mind the Graph as examples. Authors must confirm that the tool they use grants the necessary rights for publication.

  • Cover art may be allowed only with prior permission from the editor and publisher.

This restriction on illustrating or altering evidence is separate from AI used as a declared research method, such as AI-assisted imaging. Elsevier addresses that use separately and requires reproducible Methods documentation; it does not authorize a general image generator to invent experimental observations.

The implication for a prompt-based draft is this: a reviewed explanatory schematic might fall under Elsevier’s permitted category if you disclose it correctly. A graphical abstract generated with a general-purpose image model would not. Medical Illustration does not claim to be the icon-library tool Elsevier lists in that FAQ. Check the journal and the tool’s licensing terms before you rely on a draft for a graphical abstract.

Springer Nature, and Nature’s figure guide

Springer Nature’s current policy page on AI use in manuscript preparation, checked on 14 November 2026, uses a risk-assessment approach rather than a single sentence banning or allowing all AI figures.

In its writing framework, “creating content from text prompts or without verifiable source data or material” is listed as a red, not-permitted use. In the section on visual content, AI may be used to create, modify, enhance, or analyse figures where the use is transparent, lawful, and does not compromise the scholarly record, and where several conditions are met: disclosure of the model and purpose; underlying data, source material, methods, or computational outputs that can be inspected and attributed; human review; a visual output that represents the underlying evidence; and no infringement of copyright or other rights. Examples include charts from datasets, diagrams derived from author-developed content, and figures generated from reviewed code.

The same page is explicit about the other side: “AI generated visual content that is not derived from independently verifiable data, source material, methods, computational outputs or author-developed content is considered opaque and is not permitted by Springer Nature policy.” Disclosure includes an AI declaration and a caption or legend.

Separately, the accessible Nature research figure guide on image integrity states that generative AI, including content-aware image editing, is not permitted in figures. The Nature Portfolio AI policy page could not be retrieved during the 14 November review; its current wording is not verified here.

Read the applicable journal instructions alongside these policies. A prompt-only anatomy illustration without verifiable source material does not satisfy the Springer Nature source-verification condition. The accessible Nature figure guide is stricter. Ask the journal if the pages appear inconsistent for your proposed use.

Science journals (AAAS)

The official Science editorial-policy page returned HTTP 403 on 14 November 2026. Its current image-permission and disclosure wording could not be verified in this review. Read the live page or contact the journal before preparing a submission figure. Rules for individual Science Partner Journals must not be presented as rules for all Science journals.

What this means if you use Medical Illustration

Medical Illustration can draft explanatory figures, diagrams, and graphical-abstract compositions from a text prompt or a reference image. Paid plans, on the pricing page checked on 14 November 2026, include a commercial-use license; the license still requires you to review outputs before distribution and limits free-plan images to non-commercial and evaluation uses.

That license does not override a journal. In particular:

  • Do not use the tool to invent or alter primary experimental or patient images.

  • Do not submit a generative figure to a Nature journal following the figure guide unless the journal explicitly confirms an applicable exception. For Science, verify the current policy directly; this review could not retrieve it.

  • For Elsevier explanatory images, a reviewed diagram with a full caption disclosure may be in scope; a graphical abstract may not be, if the journal treats the tool as general-purpose generative AI. Check before you rely on it.

  • For Springer Nature, ask whether the figure is derived from verifiable, attributable inputs that an editor can inspect. A prompt-only image usually is not.

If you do submit a permitted explanatory figure, keep the tool name and version, the prompt or source materials, and a note of who reviewed the labels. Use the scientific figure generator or medical diagram generator as a drafting step, not as the last word on whether the figure can appear in print.

A simple submission checklist

Open the journal’s current official policy. Classify the figure (explanatory schematic, data visualization, primary research image, graphical abstract, or cover art). If the category is not allowed, stop. If it is allowed with conditions, meet every condition: human review, caption disclosure, manuscript declaration, and any Methods text. Do not list the tool as an author.