AI 생성 그림의 학술지 정책 가이드
편집 자료 확인 날짜:

This guide compares official policies for AI-generated figures. In the review on 14 November 2026, the ICMJE, Elsevier, Springer Nature manuscript-preparation, and Nature figure-integrity pages were accessible. The Science editorial-policy and Nature Portfolio AI pages could not be retrieved, so their current wording is not asserted here. Use the table as a starting point, then read your target journal’s own instructions.
A shorter narrative version is in the journal policies article.
Check the journal before you generate a submission figure
If you are only exploring a teaching diagram, generate a draft and have a qualified person review it. If you intend to submit the figure, read the journal’s current official AI and image policy first. Some publishers do not allow generative figures. Others allow only certain explanatory images, with a caption disclosure and a manuscript declaration.
Read the shorter article · Draft a scientific figure
How to use this guide
Identify the journal and open its current official policy. Use the links below only as a map.
Classify your figure: explanatory schematic, data visualization from your data, primary research image, graphical abstract, or cover art.
If the category is not allowed, stop. Do not try to repair a banned category with a caption.
If the category is allowed with conditions, meet every condition and keep a record of the tool, version, prompt or source materials, and the human review.
Do not list an AI tool as an author.
JAMA and Cell Press are outside this comparison. A publisher-wide summary is not a substitute for the instructions of an individual journal.
Policy comparison and verification status (14 November 2026)
| Source | Official page | Summary or verification limit |
|---|---|---|
| ICMJE recommendations | Authors and contributors; Use of AI by authors | Disclose AI-assisted technologies, including image creators, at submission, in the cover letter and in the work. Describe figure generation in the Methods. AI tools cannot be authors. Humans must review output. Nondisclosure may be treated as misconduct. |
| Elsevier | Generative AI policies for journals (page notes an update in June 2026) | Explanatory images may be created with AI if disclosed in the caption and in a declaration. Data visualizations only from real, reproducible data. No AI creation or alteration of primary research images. No general-purpose generative AI tools for graphical abstracts. Cover art only with prior permission. |
| Springer Nature | AI use in manuscript preparation | Visual content may be permitted when it is derived from verifiable, attributable inputs, is reviewed by a person, represents the underlying evidence, and is disclosed. Opaque AI visuals from text prompts without verifiable source material are not permitted. |
| Nature research figure guide | Image integrity | “The use of any sort of generative AI in figures is not permitted. This includes content-aware editing tools in Photoshop.” |
| Nature Portfolio | Artificial Intelligence (AI) | Could not be retrieved during this review. Read the live policy alongside the accessible Nature figure guide and the target journal’s instructions. |
| Science journals (AAAS) | Science journals editorial policies | Access returned HTTP 403 during this review. Current wording is not verified here. Consult the journal directly; a Science Partner Journal’s policy does not establish the policy for all Science journals. |
ICMJE
Journals following ICMJE should require authors to disclose, at submission, whether they used AI-assisted technologies such as large language models, chatbots, or image creators. Authors should describe that use in the cover letter and, where applicable, in the manuscript. If AI was used for figure generation, describe it in the Methods. Review and edit the output. Do not list the tool as an author. Do not treat AI-generated material as a primary source. Official wording is on the two ICMJE pages linked in the table.
Elsevier, including graphical abstracts
Elsevier’s policy is the most granular of the pages we checked. Explanatory images (flow charts, decision trees, timelines, schematic conceptual illustrations, experimental workflow diagrams) may be supported by AI tools if you disclose the specific tool, version, and how it was used in each caption and in a general AI declaration. Data visualizations must be derived from your data with reproducible methods. Primary research images must not be created or altered with AI tools.
This restriction on illustrating or altering evidence is separate from AI used as a declared research method, such as AI-assisted imaging. Elsevier addresses that use separately and requires reproducible Methods documentation; it does not authorize a general image generator to invent experimental observations.
Graphical abstracts are treated separately. Elsevier states that general-purpose generative AI image tools must not be used to create them, and it encourages dedicated scientific illustration tools. Its FAQ names BioRender and Mind the Graph as examples. Medical Illustration does not claim to be in that example list. If you are preparing a graphical abstract for an Elsevier journal, confirm the journal’s expectation and the tool’s publication rights before you start.
Suggested caption language appears on Elsevier’s official page (for example, noting that an initial image was generated with a named tool and then edited and reviewed by the authors). Use Elsevier’s current wording, not a paraphrase, if you submit there.
Springer Nature and Nature
Springer Nature’s current manuscript-preparation policy is a risk-assessment framework. Content created from text prompts without verifiable source data or material is listed as not permitted in the writing framework. For visual content, the test is whether an editor can inspect how the image was created and whether the underlying evidence can be verified. Charts from datasets, diagrams derived from author-developed content, and figures generated from reviewed code are given as examples of uses that may be permitted with disclosure. Opaque generative images are not permitted.
The Nature research figure guide remains stricter in its wording: no generative AI in figures, including content-aware Photoshop tools. If you are submitting to a Nature journal, treat that guide as binding unless the journal tells you otherwise in writing.
Science journals
The official Science editorial-policy page could not be retrieved on 14 November 2026 (HTTP 403). We therefore do not present its current permission or disclosure rules as verified. Open the linked page yourself or ask the target journal’s editorial office before preparing an AI-assisted submission figure. Do not substitute rules from a Science Partner Journal for those of the journal you are submitting to.
What this means for Medical Illustration drafts
Medical Illustration can produce explanatory drafts, diagrams, and graphical-abstract compositions from text or a reference image. Paid plans include a commercial-use license; the license still requires review, and free-plan images are limited. That license does not change any journal rule.
Do not use the product to invent or alter primary experimental or patient images. Do not assume a prompt-only anatomy illustration will be accepted by Springer Nature or by a Nature or Science journal. For Elsevier, a reviewed explanatory schematic with full disclosure may be in scope; a graphical abstract may not be.
If a figure is allowed, keep the tool name, version, prompt or source, and the name of the person who reviewed the labels. Use the scientific figure generator, medical diagram generator, or graphical abstract generator as a drafting step only.
자주 묻는 질문
AI로 만든 의료 그림을 학술 논문에 사용할 수 있나요?
학술지가 해당 유형의 이미지를 허용하고 자격을 갖춘 사람이 검토했으며 도구를 규정대로 공개한 경우에만 가능합니다. 일부 출판사는 생성 그림을 금지하거나 편집자의 허가를 요구합니다.
모든 출판사의 규정이 같나요?
아닙니다. Elsevier, Springer Nature, Nature 연구 그림 가이드, ICMJE 권고와 Science 학술지는 서로 다른 요건을 정합니다. 항상 투고 학술지의 최신 공식 페이지를 확인하세요.
어떤 내용을 공개해야 하나요?
출판사에 따라 다릅니다. 도구 이름과 버전, 사용 목적, 그림 설명의 표시, 원고 내 선언과 경우에 따른 방법 설명이 흔히 요구됩니다. ICMJE는 투고 첨부 편지에도 공개하도록 요구합니다. AI 도구를 저자로 기재해서는 안 됩니다.
현미경·면역블롯·환자 이미지에 AI를 사용할 수 있나요?
Medical Illustration으로 원본 연구 이미지나 환자 영상을 만들거나 변조하지 마세요. Elsevier는 이러한 증거의 조작을 금지하며, 공개된 연구 방법으로 사용되는 AI는 별도로 다룹니다. 공식 정책과 투고 학술지의 요구 사항을 확인하세요.
프롬프트 도구로 Elsevier용 그래피컬 앱스트랙을 만들어도 되나요?
Elsevier는 범용 생성형 AI 이미지 도구로 그래피컬 앱스트랙을 만드는 것을 금지하고 전용 과학 일러스트 도구를 권장합니다. Medical Illustration은 그 예시 도구 목록에 해당한다고 주장하지 않습니다. 초안에 의존하기 전에 학술지에 확인하세요.
상업적 이용 허가가 있으면 학술지에서 그림을 받아주나요?
아닙니다. 이용 허가와 학술지 정책은 별개입니다. Medical Illustration 유료 요금제는 상업적 이용을 포함하지만 투고 학술지의 규정도 지켜야 합니다.
검토할 초안 만들기
그림 초안을 만든 뒤 자격을 갖춘 전문가에게 모든 라벨의 검토를 요청하세요.
Sources and verification notes (14 November 2026)
Elsevier: generative AI policies for journals
Springer Nature: AI use in manuscript preparation
Nature: figure image integrity was accessible; the Nature Portfolio AI policy could not be retrieved.
Science: editorial policies returned HTTP 403; current wording is not verified here.